It’s late evening, the sun is setting, the end of a long day. I’m sitting in a Metro North train car on my commute home reflecting on the day. Cool air streams down from the overhead vents.
Summer has arrived in Manhattan, and despite this 23 square mile piece of land being surrounded on all sides by water, the Island can be 10-20° F hotter than it is at home in the suburbs – billions of tons of concrete, steel and asphalt broiling under the late day Sun.
I had read his essay the prior week, and it was still rooting its way into my core, into the marrow of my bones. I flip open my e-reader to re-read the passages that I have highlighted in George Yancy’s “Is Your God Dead?” where he speaks to leaving our God in our places of worship or in our good intentions.
Perhaps by remaining in your “holy” places, you have sacrificed looking in the face of your neighbor on the street. You know the one: the one who smells “bad” because she hasn’t bathed in days; the one who carries her home on her body; the one who begs. Surely you’ve seen that “unholy” face. I’ve seen you suddenly look away, making sure not to make eye contact with the “unclean.” Perhaps you’re preoccupied with texting, consumed by a work or family matter…Your refusal to stop, to linger, to look into her eyes, has already done its damage. Your body has already left a mark in its absence, in its fleeing the scene.
If there is a shred of life left in ‘your’ God, full resuscitation might begin with remaining in the presence of that suffering face.
We should be mortified by the inadequacy and superficiality of our anguish when we witness the suffering of others, the sort of anguish that should make us weep until our eyes are red and swollen and bring sleepless nights and agonizing days. We are a generation that has lost the capacity for outrage.
I have been troubled by the lack of outrage against poverty, white racism and supremacism, sexism, classism, homophobia, bullying, building walls, “alternative facts,” visa/immigration bans and xenophobia. Heschel reminds us that when we establish a way of life predicated upon a lie, ‘the world can turn into a nightmare.’
I return back to my day, and return to two events that took seconds, yet will replay who knows how long. Both events occur in the same New York city block. I’m rushing (again! why? to what? for what?) to catch my train.
We, other commuters and tourists, stand behind a large man at the cross-walk, all waiting for the Walk sign. He stands alone, while the Group stands in an established safe zone, a half-moon perimeter several feet back. He’s wearing a soiled jacket, with his head bowed down heavily towards the curb. A red double decker tour bus passes, leaving a wind blast in its wake. We’re smothered with his body odor. Amid snorts and grimaces, we leave him behind as he limps across the street. Our nostrils have not yet cleared and another Man approaches: “Sir, please, can you spare some change? Miss, can you spare me a dollar for a sandwich? Sir, what about you? Can you help me out? I’m hungry.”
Yancy continues: None of us is innocent. “Above all, the prophets remind us of the moral state of a people,” Heschel reminds us. “Few are guilty, but all are responsible.”
And I sit and think – – what if one is responsible and guilty? Then what?
That’s Eiko Ojala‘s illustration above titled “I found my silence.”
I found mine too.
Notes:
- Link to the entire NY Times essay by George Nancy: “Is Your god Dead?”
- Post Title Inspiration: Comedian Bill Murray joked when he said “The fact there’s a highway to hell and only a stairway to heaven says a lot about anticipated traffic numbers.”
- Related Posts: Commuting
- Illustration: Eiko Ojala (Estonia) with “I Found My Silence”

Leave a Reply